Cement vs Acrylic Stucco - What is the Difference

When it comes to choosing the right exterior finish for your home, stucco remains a top contender for its durability, versatility, and aesthetic appeal. But deciding between acrylic stucco and traditional cement stucco can make a big difference—not just in how your home looks, but also in how it performs over time. Each option brings something unique to the table, and knowing the differences can help you make the right call for your home.

Acrylic Stucco

What Is Acrylic Stucco?

Also known as synthetic stucco, acrylic stucco is made from acrylic resins and polymers. It looks similar to textured paint and often contains small aggregates (like crushed stone) to give it a refined, modern finish.

Key benefits of acrylic stucco:

• Unlimited color options: Acrylic finishes can be custom-tinted to almost any color. That kind of flexibility allows homeowners to get creative and personalize their exterior in ways that traditional stucco can’t quite match.

• Resists cracking: Its flexible nature helps prevent hairline cracks that are common in rigid materials.

• Durability: Often applied with a high-impact mesh layer and a high-impact base coat making the finish strong against physical damage and weather. These layers aren’t just for extreme cases—they’re ideal for high-traffic areas like entryways, stairways, kids’ play zones, sports facilities, or any spot prone to impacts or harsh weather. The Sto high IMPACT system, we use, resisted over 54,900 simulated woodpecker strikes without penetration

• Modern look: Sleek, consistent texture and bold colors make acrylic stucco a favorite for contemporary designs.

• Low maintenance: Doesn't need repainting unless you want a new look.

• Highly energy-efficient: Because acrylic stucco is often part of an EIFS system, it adds a continuous layer of rigid foam insulation to the exterior of the home. This helps significantly reduce energy loss by minimizing thermal bridging—keeping your home warmer in winter and cooler in summer.

• Breathable: Contrary to common myths, modern EIFS systems are designed with drainage and permeability in mind. The foam insulation layer used in EIFS helps allow moisture vapor to escape while keeping bulk water out—improving air quality and preventing moisture buildup inside your walls.

💡 Did you know? EIFS can increase your home’s R-value (a measure of insulation) by up to 20% or more, depending on the system and thickness—making it one of the most energy-efficient cladding options available.

However, all these benefits come with a higher price tag. Acrylic stucco tends to be more expensive than traditional cement stucco, both in materials and labor.

Traditional Stucco

What Is Traditional Cement Stucco?

Cement stucco is the classic stucco option—made from a mix of cement, sand, lime, and water. It gives homes a textured, organic look that works beautifully with Mediterranean, Southwestern, and traditional architectural styles.

Advantages of cement stucco:

• Timeless texture: From smooth swirls to rugged trowel finishes, cement stucco offers a wide range of textures and patterns.

• Natural appearance: Earthy, muted tones give your home a warm, traditional feel.

• Breathable surface: Allows moisture to escape, helping the walls stay dry.

• Cost-effective: Cement stucco is usually less expensive than acrylic, making it a smart choice for larger homes or tighter budgets.

That said, cement stucco is more rigid and prone to hairline cracks—especially in areas with shifting soil or frequent temperature changes. It also doesn’t hold color as well over time, often requiring repainting or recoating after several years.

The Best of Both Worlds

Can’t decide between the two? Good news: you don’t have to. Many homeowners choose a hybrid approach—using traditional cement stucco for its structure and texture, topped with an acrylic finish coat for enhanced color retention and durability. This gives you the character of cement with the performance of acrylic.

Final Thoughts

The choice between acrylic and traditional stucco depends on your priorities:

• Choose acrylic stucco if you want bold color, a smooth modern look, and extra durability.

• Choose cement stucco if you prefer a natural, textured finish and want a more budget-friendly option.

At Titan Stucco, we specialize in both systems and can help you find the right match for your home’s style, climate, and budget. Whether you're after a fresh, modern vibe or a timeless, rustic charm—we'll help you get there with a finish that's built to last.